Metropolitan Trophy Race
Sheepshead Bay Speedway
2 Mile Board Oval
75 Laps/150 Miles
May 13, 1916
| Finish | Start | Driver | Car # | Sponsor/Name | Chassis | Engine | Laps | Status |
Points |
| 1 | 5 | Eddie Rickenbacker | 11 | Maxwell | Maxwell | Maxwell | 75 | 1:33:31 96.239 | 600 |
| 2 | 3 | Jules DeVigne | 7 | Delage | Delage | Delage | 75 | 1:35:11 94.554 | 320 |
| 3 | 10 | Ira Vail | 21 | Hudson | Hudson | Hudson | 75 | 1:38:44 91.154 | 170 |
| 4 | 7 | Charles Devlin | 14 | Duesenberg | Duesenberg | Duesenberg | 75 | 1:43:03 87.336 | 90 |
| 5 | 8 | George Adams | 17 | Adams | Adams | Duesenberg | 75 | 1:51:00 81.081 | 55 |
| 6 | 1 | Bert Watson | 4 | J. J. R. | RiChard | Duesenberg | 70 | Flagged | 35 |
| 7 | 9 | Dario Resta | 19 | Peugeot | Peugeot | Peugeot | 58 | Engine | |
| 8 | 6 | Aldo Franchi | 12 | Pusun | Peugeot | Sunbeam | 25 | Out | |
| 9 | 2 | Carl Limberg | 6 | Delage | Delage | Delage | 14 | Wrecked - fatal | |
| 10 | 4 | Ralph Mulford | 9 | Peugeot | Peugeot | Peugeot | 8 | Broken piston | |
| -- | -- | Johnny Aitken | 3 | Peugeot | Peugeot | Peugeot | -- | Did not qualify | |
| -- | -- | Josef Christiaens | 1 | Sunbeam | Sunbeam | Sunbeam | -- | Did not qualify | |
| -- | -- | Billy Chandler | 16 | Crawford | Crawford | Duesenberg | -- | Did not qualify | |
| -- | -- | Dave Lewis | 2 | Crawford | Crawford | Duesenberg | -- | Did not qualify | |
| -- | -- | Eddie O'Donnell | X | Duesenberg | Duesenberg | Duesenberg | -- | Did not qualify | |
| -- | -- | Pete Henderson | 5 | Maxwell | Maxwell | Maxwell | -- | Did not qualify | |
| -- | -- | Jack LeCain | X | Delage | Delage | Delage | -- | Did not appear | |
| -- | -- | Grover Bergdoll | X | Erwin 40 | X | X | -- | Did not appear | |
| -- | -- | Gene Stecher | X | Erwin 40 | X | X | -- | Did not appear | |
| -- | -- | Charles Thompson | X | Mulford Olsen | X | X | -- | Did not appear |
Known riding mechanics in this race:
| Finish | Start | Driver | Mechanic | Car # | Sponsor/Name | Chassis | Engine | Laps | Status |
| 1 | 5 | Eddie Rickenbacker | Clyde Latta | 11 | Maxwell | Maxwell | Maxwell | 75 | 1:33:31 96.239 |
| 2 | 3 | Jules DeVigne | Charles Dellocchio | 7 | Delage | Delage | Delage | 75 | 1:35:11 94.554 |
| 3 | 10 | Ira Vail | Louis Luddiman | 21 | Hudson | Hudson | Hudson | 75 | 1:38:44 91.154 |
| 4 | 7 | Charles Devlin | Barney Newgard | 14 | Duesenberg | Duesenberg | Duesenberg | 75 | 1:43:03 87.336 |
| 5 | 8 | George Adams | Bert Edwards | 17 | Adams | Adams | Duesenberg | 75 | 1:51:00 81.081 |
| 6 | 1 | Bert Watson | Harry Kientsch | 4 | J. J. R. | RiChard | Duesenberg | 70 | Flagged |
| 7 | 9 | Dario Resta | Bob Dahnke | 19 | Peugeot | Peugeot | Peugeot | 58 | Engine |
| 8 | 6 | Aldo Franchi | Nicholas Zwick | 12 | Pusun | Peugeot | Sunbeam | 25 | Out |
| 9 | 2 | Carl Limberg | Roxie Palotti | 6 | Delage | Delage | Delage | 14 | Wrecked - fatal |
| 10 | 4 | Ralph Mulford | James Stakes | 9 | Peugeot | Peugeot | Peugeot | 8 | Broken piston |
| -- | -- | Johnny Aitken | Maurice Becker | 3 | Peugeot | Peugeot | Peugeot | -- | Did not qualify |
| -- | -- | Josef Christiaens | Frank Bill | 1 | Sunbeam | Sunbeam | Sunbeam | -- | Did not qualify |
| -- | -- | Billy Chandler | Art Johnson | 16 | Crawford | Crawford | Duesenberg | -- | Did not qualify |
| -- | -- | Dave Lewis | Jim Alexander | 2 | Crawford | Crawford | Duesenberg | -- | Did not qualify |
| -- | -- | Pete Henderson | Ralph Kriplen | 5 | Maxwell | Maxwell | Maxwell | -- | Did not qualify |
| Lap Leaders | Total | Laps |
| Dario Resta | 44 | 15-58 |
| Eddie Rickenbacker | 17 | 59-75 |
| Carl Limberg | 14 | 1-14 |